• 9964432222
  • Mail Us
  • Appointment
  • Locate Us
  • Chat Now
  • Courses
  • Login
  • Register
Manifest IAS
JournalsOfIndia
Manifest Learning Academy
  • Home
  • SNIPPETSfor Prelims
  • ARTICLESfor Mains
  • BROWSEBY SOURCE
  • DOWNLOADS
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • SNIPPETSfor Prelims
  • ARTICLESfor Mains
  • BROWSEBY SOURCE
  • DOWNLOADS
No Result
View All Result
JournalsOfIndia
No Result
View All Result
Home Law & Policy

SC directive on Anti-defection law

March 12, 2020
in Law & Policy
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
422
VIEWS
Share on WhatsAppShare on TelegramShare on Facebook
image_pdfMake PDF

Source: The Hindu

Manifest pedagogy: Anti-defection policies were a good step to safeguard voter interest in a democracy, however, lately, the provision of 2/3rd representation as a whole defecting has set a dangerous precedent and therefore needs careful study.

In news: The Supreme Court has given a directive to parliament regarding anti-defection law.

Placing it in syllabus: Anti-defection law (ADL)

Static dimensions: ADL provisions and limitations 

Current dimensions:

  • Need for directive
  • Importance of the directive 
  • Criticisms of the directive 

Content:

ADL provisions and limitations:

  • Through the 52nd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1985, the 10th Schedule of the Constitution, which contains the anti-defection law, was added to the Constitution.
  • The purpose is to curb political defection by the legislators. 
  • There are two grounds on which a member of a legislature can be disqualified.

-> If the member voluntarily gives up the membership of the party: Voluntarily giving up the membership is not the same as resigning from a party. Even without resigning, a legislator can be disqualified if by his conduct the Speaker/Chairman of the concerned House draws a reasonable inference that the member has voluntarily given up the membership of his party.

-> If a legislator votes in the House against the direction of his party and his action is not condoned by his party, he can be disqualified. 

An exception provided in the 10th schedule is, if there is a merger between two political parties and two-thirds of the members of a legislature party agree to the merger, they will not be disqualified.

Limitations:

  • It affects the independence of MPs/ MLAs by curbing their freedom for speech and expression.
  • Only the Speaker has the discretion to decide whether the resignations were voluntary or genuine. But there are many cases where speakers have not acted as impartial umpires on issues related to defection. 
  • Speakers aren’t legally bound to take a decision on any anti-defection case within a timeframe and this discretion has helped ruling parties on various occasions in several states.

Need for directive:

Though the law has been able to curb the evil of defection to a great extent, a very alarming trend of legislators defecting in groups to another party is visible.

The speaker who also belongs to a particular political party could be influenced by political interests. In many cases, the disqualification petition to be decided within a reasonable period of time has lingered on for an indefinite period.

(E.g. Recently the disqualification petition against seven of its MLAs had been pending at Nagaland Legislative Assembly speaker’s court for 10 months) 

In the recent case of Manipur Congress MLAs’ disqualification case, the three-judge bench of the SC headed by Justice R.F. Nariman directed the speaker of the Manipur Legislative Assembly to dispose of the case within four weeks, failing which the petitioner could approach the high court (HC). 

Proposed changes:

  • Supreme Court urged Parliament to set up an independent permanent tribunal to decide disqualification petitions within a reasonable time.
  • The Constitution would be amended to “substitute” Speakers of the Lok Sabha and Assemblies as “arbiter of disputes concerning disqualifications” which arise under the Tenth Schedule “with a permanent tribunal”.
  • The tribunal could be headed by a retired SC judge or a retired chief justice of an HC or some outside independent mechanism to ensure that such disputes are decided swiftly and impartially.
  • This move is done to give teeth to the anti-defection law instead of leaving it to the Speaker’s discretion who continues to belong to a particular political party either de jure or de facto.

Importance of the directive:

In Kihoto Hollohan (1992) case, the SC had upheld the validity of the anti-defection law and had also made the Speaker’s order subject to judicial review on limited grounds. It had made it clear that the court’s jurisdiction would not come into play unless the Speaker passes an order, leaving no room for intervention prior to adjudication. 

In the Rajendra Singh Rana case of 2007, the constitution bench set aside the Uttar Pradesh Speaker’s order refusing to disqualify 13 BSP defectors on the grounds that he had failed to exercise his jurisdiction to decide whether they had attracted disqualification, while recognising a ‘split’ in the legislature party.

In the recent Manipur assembly case, the court gave a deadline of four weeks to the Manipur Assembly Speaker to decide the disqualification question in a legislator’s case. 

As “failure to exercise jurisdiction” is a recognised stage at which the court can now intervene, the court has thus opened a window for judicial intervention in cases in which Speakers refuse to act. 

If the SC directive is followed without any constraints, it augurs well for the enforcement of the law against defection in letter and spirit.

Criticisms against the directive:

  • Violates Separation of powers principle 
  • Violates Article 122 which bars courts from inquiring into the proceedings of the Parliament.
  • Anti Defection proceedings fall under ‘ parliamentary proceedings.

 

image_pdfMake PDF
Tags: GS-2Mains

Related Posts

Parliament is North Star of Democracy

Parliament is North Star of Democracy

February 6, 2023
Who are puisne judges?

Who are puisne judges?

February 2, 2023
AISHE report

AISHE report

January 31, 2023
Grievance appellate committees to address users complaints against internet-based platforms

Grievance appellate committees to address users complaints against internet-based platforms

January 30, 2023
Euthanasia and a living will

Euthanasia and a living will

January 26, 2023
What is mandatory minimum sentencing?

What is mandatory minimum sentencing?

January 26, 2023
Law on lawyers advertising their work in India

Law on lawyers advertising their work in India

January 25, 2023
What are emergency provisions under the Information Technology Rules, 2021

What are emergency provisions under the Information Technology Rules, 2021

January 24, 2023
NCERT notified India’s first national assessment regulator- PARAKH

NCERT notified India’s first national assessment regulator- PARAKH

January 24, 2023
Rural Health Statistics 2021-2022

Rural Health Statistics 2021-2022

January 23, 2023
Please login to join discussion

Our Offline Classroom Student

CONGRATULATIONS TO 2021 TOPPERS !!!

Rank 171 Kumar Shivashish
Rank 250 Sahithya
Rank 263 Sumit Kumar Thakur
Rank 311 Deepak Ramachandra Shet
Rank 455 Ravinandan B M

February 2023
MTWTFSS
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728 
« Jan    

Browse by Category

  • Agriculture
  • Disaster Management
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Ethics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Geography
  • Governance
  • History
  • Law & Policy
  • Opinion
  • People in News
  • Places in News
  • Science & Tech
  • Security
  • Society
  • Sports
  • Uncategorized

Browse by Tags

AIR All India Radio BBC Business Line Business Standard dow Down to Earth DownToEarth DTE Economic Times ET FAO Financial Express GS-1 GS-2 GS-3 GS-4 Hindustan Times IE India & the world Indian express Indiatoday India today Kurukshetra Livelihoods portal LiveMint Mains News News Paper Newspaper PIB Prelims PRS India RSTV Science Reporter Survey The Hindu The India Express The Indian Express The Print the wire Times of India TOI TOPPERS Yojana
JournalsOfIndia

Our vision is to orient the readers to grasp the facts objectively and analyse critically. In the rush of reaching first to the readers, the websites miss the balanced opinion, which is the need of the hour. We aim to reach the readers with more crispness, preciseness and relevance. We bring the articles in UPSC way for the civil services aspirants and the Wisest Way for general readers.

Categories

  • Agriculture
  • Disaster Management
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Ethics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Geography
  • Governance
  • History
  • Law & Policy
  • Opinion
  • People in News
  • Places in News
  • Science & Tech
  • Security
  • Society
  • Sports
  • Uncategorized

Browse by Tag

AIR All India Radio BBC Business Line Business Standard dow Down to Earth DownToEarth DTE Economic Times ET FAO Financial Express GS-1 GS-2 GS-3 GS-4 Hindustan Times IE India & the world Indian express Indiatoday India today Kurukshetra Livelihoods portal LiveMint Mains News News Paper Newspaper PIB Prelims PRS India RSTV Science Reporter Survey The Hindu The India Express The Indian Express The Print the wire Times of India TOI TOPPERS Yojana

Newsletter

The most important UPSC news and events of the day.

Get Journals daily newsletter on your inbox.

© 2020 JournalsOfIndia - A free initiative by Manifest Team.

  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Home
  • SNIPPETS
  • ARTICLES
  • BROWSE
  • DOWNLOADS
No Result
View All Result

© 2020 JournalsOfIndia - A free initiative by Manifest Team.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In