• 9964432222
  • Mail Us
  • Appointment
  • Locate Us
  • Chat Now
  • Courses
  • Login
  • Register
Manifest IAS
JournalsOfIndia
Manifest Learning Academy
  • Home
  • SNIPPETSfor Prelims
  • ARTICLESfor Mains
  • BROWSEBY SOURCE
  • DOWNLOADS
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • SNIPPETSfor Prelims
  • ARTICLESfor Mains
  • BROWSEBY SOURCE
  • DOWNLOADS
No Result
View All Result
JournalsOfIndia
No Result
View All Result
Home Law & Policy

Anti-defection law and its effect on politics

June 29, 2022
in Law & Policy
Reading Time: 7 mins read
0
Anti-defection law and its effect on politics
1.8k
VIEWS
Share on WhatsAppShare on TelegramShare on Facebook
image_pdfMake PDF

Manifest Pedagogy:

Defections within political parties are on rise in various states. Although the Anti-defection Law makes an effort to reduce these occurrences, it has not been adequately effective thus far. There is also a need for building up a political consensus so that there is room for political expression in the Parliament for the members. There is an urgent need for a watchdog to stop future incidences of defection and escalating levels of corruption within the Indian political system. 

In news– Political crisis in Maharashtra has brought back the focus on effectiveness of Anti-Defection law.

Placing it in syllabus: Polity

Static Dimensions:

  • About Tenth Schedule of the Constitution (Anti defection)
  • Advantages of Anti-Defection Law
  • Court Cases related to Defection

Current Dimensions:

  • Issues with Anti Defection Law
  • Best Practices around the world
  • Recommendations of various bodies on reforming the Anti-defection law

Content:

Tenth Schedule of the Constitution (Anti defection)-

  • The Tenth Schedule, which was inserted in the Constitution by the Constitution (Fifty-Second Amendment) Act, 1985, provides for the disqualification of Members of Parliament and state legislatures who defect.
  • Objective: Intended to strengthen the fabric of Indian Parliamentary democracy by curbing unprincipled and unethical political defections.
  • Disqualification-
    • If a member of a house belonging to a political party:
      • Voluntarily gives up the membership of his political party, or
      • Votes, or does not vote in the legislature, contrary to the directions of his political party. However, if the member has taken prior permission, or is condoned by the party within 15 days from such voting or abstention, the member shall not be disqualified. 
    • If an independent candidate joins a political party after the election.
    • If a nominated member joins a party six months after he becomes a member of the legislature. 
  • Power to Disqualify-
    • The Chairman or the Speaker of the House takes the decision to disqualify a member. 
    • If a complaint is received with respect to the defection of the Chairman or Speaker, a member of the House elected by that House shall take the decision. 
  • Exception-
    • A person shall not be disqualified if his original political party merges with another, 
    • He and other members of the old political party become members of the new political party, 
    • He and other members do not accept the merger and opt to function as a separate group (This exception shall operate only if not less than two-thirds of the members of the party in the House have agreed to the merger). 

Advantages of Anti-Defection Law-

  • Provides stability to the government by preventing shifts of party allegiance.
  • Ensures that candidates elected with party support and on the basis of party manifestos remain loyal to the party Policies.
  • Promotes party discipline. 

Issues with Anti Defection Law-

  • Hurts accountability- By preventing parliamentarians from changing parties, it reduces the accountability of the government to the Parliament and the people
  • Interferes with the member’s freedom of speech and expression by curbing dissent against party policies. 
  • Time Limit- The law does not specify a time-period for the Presiding Officer to decide on a disqualification plea. 
  • Merger- The provision tends to safeguard the members of a political party where the original political party merges with another party subject to the condition that at least two-third of the members of the legislature party concerned have agreed to such merger.  This allows wholesale defection.
  • Role of Speaker- Many times speakers act in a biased way supporting the ruling party or not taking decisions for indefinite time as it goes against the ruling party.
  • Instead of curbing, it has promoted horse-trading of legislators which clearly go against the mandate of a democratic setup.
  • The anti-defection law leads to major decisions in the legislature being taken by a few party leaders and not by the larger body of legislators.
  • The burden of proof that there was no willingness to leave the party will always be against the legislator against whom charges are made.

Court Cases related to Defection-

  •  Kihoto Hollohan case
    • ’The Speakers/Chairmen hold a pivotal position in the scheme of Parliamentary democracy and are guardians of the rights and privileges of the House.
    • They are expected to and do take far reaching decisions in the Parliamentary democracy. 
    • Vestiture of power to adjudicate questions under the Tenth Schedule in them should not be considered exceptionable.
    • The tenure of the Speaker, who is the authority in the Tenth Schedule to decide this dispute, is dependent on the continuous support of the majority in the House and, therefore, he does not satisfy the requirement of such an independent adjudicatory authority.
    • Hence the decision of the presiding officer is subjected to Judicial Review.
    • The Speaker’s choice as the sole arbiter in the matter violates an essential attribute of the basic feature.
  • Rajendra Singh Rana vs. Swami Prasad Maurya. (2007)
    • If the Speaker fails to act on a complaint, or accepts claims of splits or mergers without making a finding, he fails to act as per the Tenth Schedule.
    • Ignoring a petition for disqualification is not merely an irregularity but a violation of constitutional duties. 

Best Practices around the world-

  • Bangladesh– The dispute is referred by the Speaker to the Election Commission.
  • Singapore– Constitution says a member must vacate his seat if he resigns, or is expelled from his party. Article 48 states that Parliament decides on any question relating to the disqualification of a member.

Recommendations of various bodies on reforming the Anti-defection law-

  • Dinesh Goswami Committee on electoral reforms (1990)
    • Disqualification should be limited to cases where (a) a member voluntarily gives up the membership of his political party, (b) a member abstains from voting, or votes contrary to the party whip in a motion of vote of confidence or motion of no-confidence.
    • The issue of disqualification should be decided by the President/ Governor on the advice of the Election Commission.
  • Halim Committee on anti-defection law (1998)
    • The words ‘voluntarily giving up membership of a political party’ be comprehensively defined.
    • Restrictions like prohibition on joining another party or holding offices in the government be imposed on expelled members.
    • The term political party should be defined clearly.
  • Law Commission 170th Report, (1999)
    • Provisions which exempt splits and mergers from disqualification to be deleted.
    • Pre-poll electoral fronts should be treated as political parties under anti-defection law.
    • Political parties should limit issuance of whips to instances only when the government is in danger.
  • Constitution Review Commission (2002)
    • Defectors should be barred from holding public office or any remunerative political post for the duration of the remaining term.
    • The vote cast by a defector to topple a government should be treated as invalid. 

Way Forward-

  • Time limit must be fixed within which the Speaker should decide the case of defection
  • To ensure impartiality of the Speaker, he/she when elected, must resign from the party to which they belong.
  • Ardent need for legislation that governs political parties in India. Such a law should bring political parties under Right to Information (RTI), strengthen intra-party democracy, etc. 
  • The scope of the law can be restricted to only those laws, where the defeat of government can lead to loss of confidence.
  • Transferring the deciding power to higher judiciary or to Election Commission may curb the menace of defection.

Mould Your Thoughts-

  1. The Anti Defection law is intended to strengthen the fabric of Indian Parliamentary democracy. Analyse. (250 Words)

Approach to the answer-

  • Write about Anti defection law and it importance
  • Issues with the usage of the law
  • Suggestion of various committees
  • Way forward and Conclusion.
image_pdfMake PDF
Tags: GS-2MainsNewspaper

Related Posts

Who are puisne judges?

Who are puisne judges?

February 2, 2023
AISHE report

AISHE report

January 31, 2023
Grievance appellate committees to address users complaints against internet-based platforms

Grievance appellate committees to address users complaints against internet-based platforms

January 30, 2023
Euthanasia and a living will

Euthanasia and a living will

January 26, 2023
What is mandatory minimum sentencing?

What is mandatory minimum sentencing?

January 26, 2023
Law on lawyers advertising their work in India

Law on lawyers advertising their work in India

January 25, 2023
What are emergency provisions under the Information Technology Rules, 2021

What are emergency provisions under the Information Technology Rules, 2021

January 24, 2023
NCERT notified India’s first national assessment regulator- PARAKH

NCERT notified India’s first national assessment regulator- PARAKH

January 24, 2023
Rural Health Statistics 2021-2022

Rural Health Statistics 2021-2022

January 23, 2023
17th Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) for 2022

17th Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) for 2022

January 20, 2023
Please login to join discussion

Our Offline Classroom Student

CONGRATULATIONS TO 2021 TOPPERS !!!

Rank 171 Kumar Shivashish
Rank 250 Sahithya
Rank 263 Sumit Kumar Thakur
Rank 311 Deepak Ramachandra Shet
Rank 455 Ravinandan B M

February 2023
MTWTFSS
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728 
« Jan    

Browse by Category

  • Agriculture
  • Disaster Management
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Ethics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Geography
  • Governance
  • History
  • Law & Policy
  • Opinion
  • People in News
  • Places in News
  • Science & Tech
  • Security
  • Society
  • Sports
  • Uncategorized

Browse by Tags

AIR All India Radio BBC Business Line Business Standard dow Down to Earth DownToEarth DTE Economic Times ET FAO Financial Express GS-1 GS-2 GS-3 GS-4 Hindustan Times IE India & the world Indian express Indiatoday India today Kurukshetra Livelihoods portal LiveMint Mains News News Paper Newspaper PIB Prelims PRS India RSTV Science Reporter Survey The Hindu The India Express The Indian Express The Print the wire Times of India TOI TOPPERS Yojana
JournalsOfIndia

Our vision is to orient the readers to grasp the facts objectively and analyse critically. In the rush of reaching first to the readers, the websites miss the balanced opinion, which is the need of the hour. We aim to reach the readers with more crispness, preciseness and relevance. We bring the articles in UPSC way for the civil services aspirants and the Wisest Way for general readers.

Categories

  • Agriculture
  • Disaster Management
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Ethics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Geography
  • Governance
  • History
  • Law & Policy
  • Opinion
  • People in News
  • Places in News
  • Science & Tech
  • Security
  • Society
  • Sports
  • Uncategorized

Browse by Tag

AIR All India Radio BBC Business Line Business Standard dow Down to Earth DownToEarth DTE Economic Times ET FAO Financial Express GS-1 GS-2 GS-3 GS-4 Hindustan Times IE India & the world Indian express Indiatoday India today Kurukshetra Livelihoods portal LiveMint Mains News News Paper Newspaper PIB Prelims PRS India RSTV Science Reporter Survey The Hindu The India Express The Indian Express The Print the wire Times of India TOI TOPPERS Yojana

Newsletter

The most important UPSC news and events of the day.

Get Journals daily newsletter on your inbox.

© 2020 JournalsOfIndia - A free initiative by Manifest Team.

  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Home
  • SNIPPETS
  • ARTICLES
  • BROWSE
  • DOWNLOADS
No Result
View All Result

© 2020 JournalsOfIndia - A free initiative by Manifest Team.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In